Pin it
I whipped up this Christmas Cookie Fudge when I was in a pinch for my cookie exchange last year. It's a tasty mix of creamy white chocolate fudge with sugar cookie vibes, and now it's my favorite holiday treat. It's incredibly simple - no oven needed! Great for bringing to last-minute gatherings, giving as thank-you gifts, or satisfying your sweet tooth cravings.
The Magic Behind This Dreamy Fudge
This fudge really seems like it took forever to make, but it's actually super quick. It gives you the best of both worlds - sugar cookies and fudge in every single bite. You'll only need about 15 minutes and ingredients you've probably got sitting in your cupboard already. I often make large batches to hand out as presents, and everyone thinks I bought them from some fancy sweet shop. It's my go-to trick when I'm short on time but want to wow people.
Gather Your Ingredients
Here's what you'll need to grab from your kitchen:
- Sugar Cookie Mix: This gives that wonderful cookie taste without any extra work.
- Sprinkles: Pick whatever colors match your holiday theme - they all look fantastic here.
- Sweetened Condensed Milk: This creates that smooth texture and binds everything together.
- White Chocolate Chips: Spend a little extra on quality ones like Ghirardelli melting wafers. Don't go for candy melts as they just won't taste as good.
Pin it
Creating Your Sweet Masterpiece
Here's my foolproof way that never fails:
Let's prep everything first. Put parchment paper in your pan with extra hanging over the edges so you can easily pull it out later. Have your sprinkles measured and ready because once we start cooking, things happen quickly.
Now for the main mixture. Empty your sweetened condensed milk into a sturdy pot - my dutch oven works wonders. Add in the sugar cookie mix and mix thoroughly. Make sure all those cookie bits are completely blended with no dry patches anywhere.
It's time for the white chocolate. Keep your heat low - and I mean really low - we don't want burnt chocolate. Toss in your chips and stir constantly. Don't stop until everything looks smooth as silk. If you notice tiny lumps, just keep stirring and they'll melt away.
Here's my handy test: touch the pot's side with your finger. If it feels warm but doesn't burn, your fudge is just right. The mixture should flow down like honey when you lift your spoon - that's when you know it's done.
Remove from heat and give it one final stir. Quickly fold in half your sprinkles with gentle motions. Don't mix too much or your colors will run and make the fudge look messy.
Pour the whole thing into your lined pan. Work quickly but don't worry about making it perfectly flat. I find an offset spatula works great for spreading. Toss the remaining sprinkles on top and push them in just a little.
Now comes the tough part - waiting! Let it cool on your countertop for about 10 minutes before putting it in the fridge. Leave it there for at least 2 hours, though overnight works even better.
When you're ready to cut, just pull up on the parchment to lift out the entire slab. Let it sit for 5 minutes, then slice with a sharp knife that's been dipped in hot water between cuts. You'll get beautiful, clean squares this way.
Storage Secrets
I've figured out some good ways to keep this fudge over time. For fridge storage, just put it in a sealed container and it'll stay tasty for around 3 weeks - though it usually gets eaten way before then at my place. Want to save it longer? Cut it up, put parchment between the layers and stick it in the freezer. It'll stay good for 6 months. Just move it to your fridge the night before you want to eat it. This method keeps the creamy texture just right.
Fun Variations To Try
My sister loves changing the sprinkles based on what holiday's coming up. Red and green for Christmas, pastel shades for Easter - you get the picture. Sometimes I add a tiny bit of vanilla or almond extract which really kicks up the flavor. Got friends who love nuts? Throw in some chopped pecans. I've even made a version with dairy-free chocolate and coconut condensed milk for my vegan neighbor - she couldn't get enough of it.
Pin it
Common Questions Answered
Folks often ask if they can make this ahead of time - absolutely you can! It actually tastes better after sitting in the fridge for a day or two. Wondering about shelf life? It'll stay good for three weeks refrigerated if you can stop yourself from finishing it all. Some people ask about swapping in regular chocolate instead of white - you can do that, but the white chocolate really makes it taste like a sugar cookie. And isn't that the whole point?
Insider Tricks For Flawless Results
After making this fudge countless times, I've learned to keep stirring while it's heating. Don't take even a moment's break or you might end up with scorched chocolate - nobody wants that. When you add those sprinkles, be really gentle because they tend to leak color everywhere. Always use good quality white chocolate since the cheap kinds just don't melt properly. And make sure it cools completely before cutting - believe me, waiting pays off with perfect squares.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why does my fudge need constant stirring?
Stirring stops the chocolate from getting burnt and helps you get a nice, even texture. If you don't stir, the bottom can get too hot and you'll end up with burnt bits in your squares.
- → How long does this fudge last?
If you keep it in a sealed container, these squares stay good for about 2 weeks in your fridge. If you leave them out, try to eat them within a week.
- → Can I use different sprinkles?
Absolutely, any sprinkle colors work well. You can match them to whatever occasion you're celebrating. Just don't add liquid food dye as it'll mess up how your fudge turns out.
- → Why isn't my fudge setting properly?
You need to use exactly the amount of condensed milk we mention and let it cool all the way in the fridge. If you try to speed things up, you'll end up with soft, gooey squares.
- → Can I freeze this fudge?
Sure thing, just wrap it carefully and it'll keep in the freezer for up to 3 months. Let it thaw in the fridge overnight before you want to eat it.