Pin it
I came up with this homemade blueberry pie fudge because I love mixing dessert flavors in surprising ways. After lots of tries, I learned the trick is to make a silky blueberry sauce that swirls right into rich white chocolate. Just a few simple things turn into a fancy treat that’s got all the cozy vibes of blueberry pie.
Getting to Know What You Need
Great results mean great ingredients. Grab white chocolate made with real cocoa butter—look for at least 30% cocoa butter on the label. Fresh berries pack the brightest punch, but wild frozen blueberries taste stronger if you can't get fresh. Always use full-fat condensed milk or your fudge won’t set right. Stick with pure vanilla—skip the fake stuff for that real deal taste.
What to Have on Hand
- For Blueberry Swirl:
- 1 cup fresh blueberries
- Organic cane sugar
- Pure cornstarch
- Filtered water
- For the Base:
- 2 cups premium white chocolate
- 14 oz full-fat condensed milk
- Pure vanilla extract
- Tools:
- Digital thermometer
- Heavy-bottom saucepan
- 8x8 metal pan
- Silicone spatula
- Fine-mesh strainer
- Parchment paper
Simple Step-by-Step Walkthrough
- Setting
- Uncover and chill in the fridge till it’s matte up top, takes about 20 minutes. Then cover it (plastic wrap shouldn’t touch it). Cool for at least 4 hours or leave it overnight if you want the best texture.
- Making the Swirls
- Get the fudge poured into your pan. Drop spoonfuls of your cooled blueberry sauce all over. Drag a skewer through in figure eights. Don’t overdo it or your colors will blend instead of swirl.
- White Chocolate Mixture
- Melt your chocolate and condensed milk on a double boiler. Try to keep the heat between 85-88°F. Swirl it gently in figure eights till it’s super smooth, then take off the heat once every piece is melted.
- Blueberry Sauce
- Pop berries, sugar, and cornstarch in your saucepan. Heat up to 185°F while mixing non-stop. When your spoon leaves a clean trail, you’re golden—should take about 7 minutes. Strain when it’s piping hot.
Helpful Hints and Fixes
If your blueberry sauce gets thick, add a bit of water while it’s still hot. Make sure your fudge base and blueberry stuff are close in temp for perfect swirls. If your chocolate looks grainy, warm cream can save it—add just a teaspoon at a time while stirring easy. Wipe your knife between slices so the squares look super neat.
Pin it
Fun Twists to Try
Switch things up with raspberries or blackberries if you want. Swirl in a mix of fruit sauces for that triple-berry look. Or toss some graham cracker crumbs in the bottom layer to bring out that pie vibe. Dress it up for parties with edible flowers or a touch of gold leaf. My personal favorite? Laying down a buttery graham crust before pouring the fudge on top.
Storing and Serving Ideas
Stack pieces between parchment in a sealed box in the fridge. Let them sit out so they’re just under room temp before biting in—that's when the flavors pop. For gifts, slice into perfect squares and set in candy cups. Fudge keeps great for one week if stored right. Just before passing around, top with some fresh berries and a few mint leaves for extra flair.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Fresh or frozen berries?
Both are good. Frozen blueberry? Toss them in straight from the freezer, don't thaw 'em first so you skip the extra juice.
- → Why strain the berries?
This gets rid of leftover seeds or skins so your swirl comes out super smooth. Scrape whatever collects under the strainer—so much flavor in there.
- → My fudge is grainy?
Try slow-melting some good white chocolate. If the heat's up too high, your fudge will go lumpy.
- → Can I freeze it?
Sure does—just wrap it up and pop it in the freezer for a couple months. Let it thaw in the fridge when you're ready for a slice.
- → How do I get neat slices?
It's so much easier if it's chilled through. Use a knife dipped in hot water and wipe between cuts for the cleanest look.
Conclusion
Sweet bites of white chocolate paired with homemade blueberry sauce give you a treat that's perfect for those steamy days. No stove or baking needed at all.