Pin it
I stumbled upon these Red Velvet Thumbprints during last year's Christmas season and they've quickly turned into my go-to holiday sweet. There's nothing like biting into that soft red cookie with its creamy cheese center - it just melts right in your mouth. Guests' faces always light up when they spot these festive treats on the table. Take my word for it, these tiny treasures work wonders at Christmas time, Valentine's celebrations, or whenever you're simply wanting something extra nice.
Charming and Tasty
The way these cookies mix that traditional red velvet flavor with the cream cheese middle is simply wonderful. That filling brings a tangy sweetness that keeps you reaching for another. They're surprisingly simple to make too - my children even join in by rolling the dough balls in glittery sugar. No matter what else sits on my cookie plate, these vanish first every single time.
Ideal Components
- Red Velvet Cookies: Grab some butter that's been sitting out - it mixes way better. You'll need plain sugar for the sweet part, a big egg right out of the fridge, and some vanilla for that cozy taste. Don't forget red gel food coloring which is crucial, basic flour, a bit of cocoa to get that chocolate hint, plus just a pinch of baking soda and salt to make it all come together nicely.
- Cream Cheese Filling: Make sure your cream cheese is really soft, your powdered sugar is strained for smoothness, and add a drop of vanilla to make it taste extra good.
- For Rolling: I really enjoy using green and red sugar or fun sprinkles to add that pretty twinkle.
Simple Cooking Directions
- Mix Your Dough
- First, whip your butter with sugar until it gets fluffy and pale. Add your egg, vanilla, and that gorgeous red coloring. In a separate bowl, mix your dry stuff, then slowly combine everything. Don't stir too much or your cookies might end up hard.
- Cool Your Dough
- Stick your dough in the fridge for 30 minutes. In a rush? Try 15 minutes in the freezer instead.
- Make Your Filling
- While waiting, blend your cream cheese mixture until it's totally smooth, then keep it cool until it's time to use.
- Form and Cook
- Roll small dough balls in sparkly sugar, push your thumb in the middle, and bake until they're barely done. If the middle parts rise up, just push them down while still warm.
- Top and Set
- After they cool down, put that creamy filling in each indent. Let them sit in the fridge a while to firm up.
Key Flavors
All the parts work together to create these amazing cookies. The butter gives them a rich softness while the sugar adds just enough sweetness. That small amount of cocoa? That's the secret to true red velvet taste. I always pick gel food coloring because it creates such a beautiful red without making the mix too wet. But the cream cheese center is truly the best bit - it's like the perfect finishing touch.
Pin it
Serving Ideas
These treats look fantastic on a holiday plate beside regular sugar cookies or gingerbread men. When I pack them as presents, I put them in see-through bags with fancy ribbons. Sometimes I'll add a thin white chocolate drizzle or some glittery sugar for special events. No matter how you dish them up, they'll always look super impressive.
Expert Baking Advice
I've made these so many times now and learned a few helpful tricks. Always go for gel coloring instead of liquid drops - it works tons better. Don't try to skip the cooling time for the dough - it really affects how they turn out. Your cream cheese needs to be completely soft before you mix it or you'll get bumps. When the dough gets sticky on your fingers, just put a bit of flour on your hands. And go easy when filling the centers or you'll create a big mess.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why chill the dough?
Chilling makes the dough sturdier so you can shape it better and stops it from spreading too much during baking.
- → What food coloring works best?
Go with gel food coloring for brighter colors without making your dough too wet.
- → Can I make these ahead?
Sure thing, just keep the filled cookies in your fridge for up to 3 days.
- → Why let cookies cool before filling?
Hot cookies will turn your cheese filling into a runny mess, so cooling is a must.
- → Can I freeze these cookies?
You can freeze the cookies without filling for up to 3 months, then add the topping after they've thawed.