Pin it
Craving two comfort foods at once? Check out this pizza grilled cheese sandwich! I whipped this up during an indecision moment between classic pizza and a grilled cheese – and wow, what a combo! Picture buttery, crunchy bread packed with gooey mozzarella, pepperoni slices, and all your fave pizza elements. It's become such a hit that my children now beg for this instead of traditional pizza!
What Makes This Special
This treat comes together in just minutes – perfect when hunger strikes fast! You can toss in any pizza additions you fancy, and even the fussiest kids get thrilled about eating it. It's basically what happens when two beloved comfort dishes merge into one amazing meal!
Grab These Items
- Butter: Gives that exterior its perfect crunch.
- Cheeses: Stretchy mozzarella and some Parmesan.
- Pizza Additions: Marinara, herbs, pepperoni slices.
- Solid Bread: Choose something that won't fall apart!
- Flavor Boosters: Italian seasoning and garlic powder work wonders.
Creating The Sandwich
- Upgrade Your Butter
- Blend room temperature butter with Italian seasoning, garlic powder and Parmesan. This mixture is game-changing!
- Stack It Up
- Smear your special butter mix onto bread slices. Add mozzarella, pepperoni, then more cheese because you deserve it!
- Start Cooking
- Use medium-low heat so cheese melts before bread burns. Give it a gentle press with your spatula to help everything get gooey.
- Turn Carefully
- Once the bottom turns golden, flip it over gently. The second side browns faster, so stay alert!
- Ready To Devour
- Slice it down the middle and enjoy that amazing cheese stretch! Don't forget warm marinara for dipping!
Pro Tips
Take your time cooking – rushing won't help. Want extra crispiness? Throw some Parmesan directly onto the buttered exterior. Using fresh mozz? Make sure to dry it properly or you'll end up with soggy bread. And always keep extra dipping sauce nearby!
Pin it
How To Enjoy
Dive in while it's still hot for the most impressive cheese pulls! Got some left? Warm them up in a skillet, not the microwave – keeps the crunch intact. Need to make it more balanced? Throw a small salad alongside to balance all that richness.
Tasty Variations
Try tucking in some baby spinach for a touch of green and pretend it's healthy! Cook everything slowly – that's what Bobby Flay would recommend. And always shred your cheese by hand rather than buying pre-shredded – Ina's right, it really does melt so much nicer!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why soften the butter first?
It spreads easier and creates a golden, crispy crust while grilling.
- → Is mozzarella the only option?
Mozzarella adds that pizza feel, but other stretchy cheeses work too.
- → Why stick to medium-low heat?
Prevents burning the bread and makes sure the cheese melts evenly.
- → Can I change up the fillings?
Absolutely! Add your favorite veggies or even extra meats.
- → What's the reason for layering the cheese?
It melts into a perfect gooey base and helps keep the pepperoni in place.