01 -
Combine softened butter, garlic seasoning, Italian herbs, and Parmesan in a bowl. Keep stirring until it’s smooth and blended.
02 -
Spread the prepared butter mix thickly on one side of every piece of bread. Make sure you go all the way to the edges.
03 -
On a sheet tray, place the slices with the buttered side facing up, gently and evenly spaced.
04 -
Set a big skillet on medium-low heat. Let it warm up so the butter doesn’t burn when cooking.
05 -
Add a slice of bread to the pan, placing the butter side down and pressing slightly so it makes full contact.
06 -
Lay down one mozzarella slice over the bread slice that’s in the skillet.
07 -
Spread six pepperoni slices on top of the mozzarella, evening them out across the cheese.
08 -
Place a second slice of mozzarella directly over the pepperoni layer.
09 -
Layer six more slices of pepperoni over the second cheese layer.
10 -
Add one last slice of mozzarella, spreading it out for even cheesiness.
11 -
Put a second slice of bread butter-side up on top to finish the sandwich.
12 -
Leave it to cook for 3–5 minutes until the bread on the bottom gets a nice golden color.
13 -
Use a spatula to flip the entire sandwich. Do it gently to avoid disturbing the layers.
14 -
Let the other side cook for another 3–5 minutes until you see a golden crisp and the cheese is melted.
15 -
Serve them hot and enjoy dipping into some warm pizza sauce!