Tasty Steak Stuffed Potato

Featured in: Family-Friendly Dinners Everyone Will Love

Make incredible restaurant-quality loaded spuds right in your kitchen with sizzling garlic steak bites and luxurious parmesan sauce. The combo of puffy potatoes, soft meat and creamy topping creates an unforgettable meal.

A woman in a kitchen with a stove and oven.
Updated on Thu, 24 Apr 2025 16:58:03 GMT
A close-up of baked potatoes topped with seasoned beef, drizzled with creamy sauce, and garnished with fresh herbs, accompanied by lemon wedges. Pin it
A close-up of baked potatoes topped with seasoned beef, drizzled with creamy sauce, and garnished with fresh herbs, accompanied by lemon wedges. | cookingkitchn.com

Juicy steak chunks in garlic butter tucked inside a fluffy baked potato, topped with a rich parmesan sauce, makes this dinner both filling and super tasty. It brings together tender beef pieces and soft potatoes for a meal that'll wow your taste buds and satisfy your hunger.

What Makes This Meal Special

You'll fall in love with this combo if you're into steaks and potatoes. It's filling, packed with amazing taste, and can be dressed up when you want something fancy for celebrations or special nights. You can't go wrong with succulent garlic butter steak pieces and that velvety parmesan topping all stuffed in a baked potato.

Shopping List

  • Russet Potatoes: Big ones, washed well and dried off.
  • Steak: Pick what you like—Ribeye, Filet, Sirloin, or NY Strip.
  • Garlic: Chop it fresh for the best kick.
  • Butter: You'll need it for cooking the meat, potatoes, and making the sauce.
  • Seasonings: Grab some Cajun mix, red pepper bits, coarse salt, and ground pepper.
  • Heavy Cream: This makes your parmesan sauce nice and thick.
  • Parmesan: Get it grated to melt smoothly into your sauce.
  • Lemon: Squeeze it fresh for that zingy touch.
  • Parsley: Chopped up fresh for sprinkling on top and boosting flavor.
  • Avocado & Olive Oil: They won't burn when you're cooking hot stuff like steak or baking taters.

How To Make It

Get Your Potatoes Ready
Turn your oven to 425°F (220°C) and put some parchment on a baking tray. Coat your spuds with olive oil, add a bit of sea salt, then pop them in to bake for about 50-60 mins until they're soft when you poke them.
Fix Up The Steak
Cut away the fatty bits and chop your meat into chunks about 2 inches big. Splash with avocado oil and sprinkle cajun mix on top. Get a cast iron pan really hot, toss in your meat and don't touch it for 2 mins, then flip it once and give it another minute. Throw in some butter and garlic, coat your meat well, and cook one more minute. Put it aside with foil on top to keep warm.
Whip Up The Sauce
Using that same pan, melt some butter with garlic. Pour in your heavy cream and stir it around for 3-5 mins till it gets thicker. Mix in your parmesan, pepper flakes, salt and pepper. Take it off the heat and throw in parsley and lemon juice.
Put It All Together
Drop each hot potato from about a foot up onto the pan to loosen the insides. Cut down the middle, put in some butter, and push gently to make room. Stuff with your steak bits, pour over your parmesan sauce, and dig in.
A tasty-looking plate showing stuffed baked potatoes topped with steak chunks and creamy white sauce, with fresh parsley sprinkled on top. Pin it
A tasty-looking plate showing stuffed baked potatoes topped with steak chunks and creamy white sauce, with fresh parsley sprinkled on top. | cookingkitchn.com

Fantastic for Every Mealtime

You can serve these loaded spuds for a simple family dinner or fancy them up for Christmas or birthday meals. The deep flavors and filling ingredients will definitely make everyone at the table happy.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What's the best type of steak to use?

Sirloin, tenderloin, ribeye or NY strip all do the job nicely. Pick what fits your taste and wallet. Just make sure it has good fat marbling for best flavor.

→ Why not poke holes in the potatoes?

Leaving the skin whole traps steam inside for extra fluffiness. The oil and salt combo naturally gives you that crispy outside.

→ Can I make components ahead?

The potatoes and sauce can be made earlier. Just warm them up gently and cook your steak fresh when you're ready to eat.

→ Why use avocado oil for the steak?

It stands up to high heat better than olive oil does, so your meat gets a nice sear without the oil burning.

→ What makes the potatoes fluffy inside?

When you drop them after cooking, it breaks up the inside while keeping the skin intact. This trick gives you that perfect fluffy middle.

Steak Stuffed Potato

Soft, airy baked potatoes packed with tender garlic steak pieces and covered in creamy parmesan topping. Beats any steakhouse meal!

Prep Time
20 Minutes
Cook Time
60 Minutes
Total Time
80 Minutes
By: Sophia


Difficulty: Difficult

Cuisine: American

Yield: 4 Servings (4)

Dietary: Gluten-Free

Ingredients

01 4 big russet potatoes.
02 4 tbsp olive oil.
03 1.5 tbsp sea salt.
04 2 lbs beef cuts (ribeye, sirloin, or NY strip).
05 2 tsp kosher salt.
06 2 tbsp crushed garlic.
07 6 tbsp butter, room temperature.
08 2 tbsp cajun spice mix.
09 4 tbsp avocado oil.
10 1 1/2 cups heavy cream.
11 2/3 cup shredded parmesan.
12 2 tbsp chopped fresh parsley.
13 2 slices of lemon.
14 1/2-1 tsp red pepper flakes.
15 1 tsp freshly ground pepper.

Instructions

Step 01

Get your oven hot at 425°F and put parchment on a baking tray for those potatoes.

Step 02

Rub each potato completely with olive oil and sprinkle sea salt all over, then lay them on your tray without poking holes.

Step 03

Pop those potatoes in the oven for about 50-60 minutes till they're soft when poked, and work on your steak stuff meanwhile.

Step 04

Snip off extra fat from your steak and chop it into 2-inch chunks, then mix with avocado oil and sprinkle cajun seasoning.

Step 05

Pour the rest of your avocado oil in a cast iron pan and let it get really hot on medium-high so your steak browns nicely.

Step 06

Drop your steak bits in and don't touch them for 2 minutes till they're golden, then just flip once and cook one more minute.

Step 07

Toss in butter and garlic to the pan with your meat, stirring until it smells good and covers all the steak pieces.

Step 08

Take the steak out to sit a bit while you make your sauce using what's left in the pan plus the butter, garlic, and cream.

Step 09

Let that cream sauce bubble down a bit, then mix in parmesan, your spices, parsley, and a squeeze of lemon.

Step 10

Take your baked potatoes and drop them from up high onto a plate to loosen the insides, then cut open and add some butter.

Step 11

Stuff each potato with chunks of steak and pour plenty of that warm parmesan cream sauce over the top.

Step 12

Bring it to the table right away while everything's still warm and the sauce is nice and creamy.

Notes

  1. Tastes just like fancy steakhouse food.
  2. Makes a romantic dinner option.
  3. Switch up the steak type if you want.
  4. Perfect for birthdays or anniversaries.

Tools You'll Need

  • Heavy iron pan.
  • Cookie sheet.
  • Baking parchment.

Allergy Information

Please check ingredients for potential allergens and consult a health professional if in doubt.
  • Milk products (butter, cream, parmesan).

Nutrition Facts (Per Serving)

It is important to consider this information as approximate and not to use it as definitive health advice.
  • Calories: 890
  • Total Fat: 52 g
  • Total Carbohydrate: 45 g
  • Protein: 48 g